Gadgets

NYT unleashes a Storm against new Blackberry

by Stevie Smith - Nov 28 2008, 16:32

Talkback

Add your comment (no registration required)

page: 1 

CliffNov 28th, 2008 - 16:47:48

The Storm is a 'smart' phone, which explains why Pogue had such a bad time with the phone.

Report this comment

johnNov 28th, 2008 - 17:25:11

He's just an apple fan boy- he lost credibility a long time ago...- He's going to lose his job soon anyway- just watch

Report this comment

STNov 28th, 2008 - 18:37:21

I am a happy Storm customer. I have had a couple blackberries over the last 4 years and have developed a bit of a crackberry habit. At the same time I do like to show off my kids pictures and listen to a bit of music. Until now I would have had to go to an Iphone to get this capability.

There is no question that the new tactile touchscreen is superior to the Iphone. It does take a bit to get used to but within a couple days I have mastered it. I don't think I will ever be able to crank out an epic email on the blackberry, nor do I want to, but it is manageable for responding quickly. I am sure the software will improve the screens responsiveness soon

Add to this the other things the Iphone cannot do and the Storm is a much more powerful business tool:

1. Be used as a modem.(What is the point of wifi unless you can handle VoIP calls? and you cannot do that on Iphone)
2. View and edit MSFT office documents. This capability is superior to my old BB...
3. Replace the battery with a fresh one if it dies. This is a big plus if you are on the phone all day at tradeshow AND listening to music
4. Expandable SD memory slot.
5. Superior camera
6. Superior video quality
7. Full access to all my outlook folders. My earlier BB could not do this.

I am sure there is more but this is plenty in my view

Report this comment

robNov 28th, 2008 - 18:39:25

i must disagree. i love my storm and its not nearly as bad as he makes it sound. that guy makes up facts and figures, what an idiot. he says that everyone hates it, of the people i know with the storm , most love it. it has a few bugs which will be fixed soon with the software update released next week.

Report this comment

daveNov 29th, 2008 - 00:52:57


I will agree with all the other comments on here so far. I am typing on my new storm bow and love it. If this NY Times reporter is so smart why is he not comming up with a new phone and putting it on the market. I have had a few problems with the phone, but nothing major. I knew when I bought the phone there would be some bugs every new tech item, be it hardware or software has bugs that is why they have updates and revisions. Oh, I wish this reporter would please not say everybody cause from what I am reading slot of people like this new Storm.

Report this comment

blkmdns01Nov 29th, 2008 - 06:14:28

i was just looking up some reviews before i buy the hone and happened across pogue's review. Of all the reviews I've read, i keep hearing complaints about it not having a physical keyboard. phones are wireless now, it makes sense that eventually everything will lose a keyboard.

Report this comment

RobertNov 29th, 2008 - 12:50:31

dave's typing above on his storm says it all really - not easy to type on is it dave ?

Report this comment

EdNov 29th, 2008 - 19:27:26

Of all the posts I've read, I can't remember one regarding the limited number of colors on the Storm's camera. I suppose it seems like a really, really minor item, but I just took a picture of a cherry red Mustang and it came out as pumpkin orange. Like I said, it seems like such a small thing in the scheme of things, but then again a huge issue when you don't get an accurate representation of a picture you've taken.

On the big issues, for me anyway, again neither of which seem to get a lot of comments: the voice quality on the storm seems very good to me, and synching Outlook's calendar, contacts, and tasks on the Storm has worked well. Most comments I've read would lead one to believe the iPhone is significantly deficient compared to the Storm in both of these regards. Are these assessments valid?

Report this comment

GridlineNov 30th, 2008 - 04:46:05

Hey ST,

The reason you would want to have Wi-Fi capablility, is to take advantage of all the apps that transfer information over the internet (which is just about every single one)... not VOIP. In my opinion, a huge mistake not to include WI-FI on the storm. Most everyplace you go now has WI-FI so why not just take advantage? Plus, on the iPhone you can use apps over WI-Fi while talking on the phone over the cell network... something you can't do without WI-FI capability.

Report this comment

Bryan12Nov 30th, 2008 - 05:31:20

John,

Speaking of Pogue... 'He's just an apple fan boy'... do a little research before you start trying to get a respected tech analyst fired. He's been nothing but a fan of RIM for years.

BTW... You sound like every other person frustrated by the fact that Apple produced a superior smartphone on its first try and there's really not another viable option out there that does what the iPhone can do.


Report this comment

page: 1 

Add your comment (no registration required)

AddThis Social Bookmark Button

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Latest

BitDefender: Trojans amounted for half of threats discovered in June
Q&A: Proginet CIO Kevin Bohan
iPhone 3GS sends AT&T registers into overdrive
Apple revises support document regarding hot 3GS handsets
SingTel confirms iPhone 3GS coming to Singapore

Latest Articles on Monsters&Critics

Potter actor Rupert Grint struck by mild Swine Flu in UK
US calls North Korea's newest missile launches "not helpful"
'Holby City' star Patsy Kensit's new name, marriage
Rafsanjani: No power struggle in Iran following crisis
Zelaya's supporters flood streets before his return (News Feature)
Algerian president names first woman general
EMPA considers Israeli measures in Jerusalem obstacles to peace
Head of Honduran Catholic Church asks Zelaya to stay abroad (Extra)
OAS could suspend Honduras after post-coup leaders balk (Extra)
Nestor-Zimonjic defend Wimbledon doubles title